Critical Reasoning MCQs (Set-4)

Difficulty: Hard

Argument: A health network argues that telehealth reduced clinic waiting times because average waiting time fell after remote visits were introduced. Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?

A The service offered video visits on weekdays.
B Some patients completed visits from home.
C The network used the same waiting-room clocks.
D The average excludes patients who could not connect and later attended in person, many of whom waited longest.

Argument: A company argues that an automated hiring screen cut costs without excluding qualified applicants. Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?

A The review measured recruiter time but did not track qualified applicants rejected by the screen.
B The tool processed applications overnight.
C Recruiters received a list of recommended applicants.
D The software was updated during the trial.

Argument: A city argues that a new flood barrier protects the district because no buildings flooded after it was built. Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?

A The barrier is inspected each year.
B No storm during the observation period produced water levels near the barrier’s design limit.
C Residents received a map of the protected area.
D The city recorded building damage after storms.

Argument: A transit authority argues that its new fare policy improved access because average trips per rider increased. Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?

A The payment system accepted contactless cards.
B The agency published the new fare table.
C The analysis excludes riders who stopped traveling because the new fares were unaffordable.
D Some frequent riders made additional trips.

Argument: A regional plan claims that a new express route improved access across the region because average travel time fell. Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?

A The route includes fewer stops in the city center.
B Some commuters reached downtown faster.
C The schedule is available online.
D The calculation averages urban trips, while travel time for remote villages increased substantially.

Argument: A company says employees support a restructuring because most survey respondents approved it. Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?

A A large share of employees did not respond, and the company did not compare their views with respondents.
B The survey allowed anonymous responses.
C Employees could add comments.
D The survey was open for two weeks.

Argument: A software firm says its update reduced security incidents because fewer alerts were recorded. Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?

A The update included a security patch.
B The update also disabled one monitoring rule that had generated many of the alerts.
C The firm kept a release log.
D The software was installed on the same servers.

Argument: A manufacturer says its climate plan lowered total emissions because its own factory emissions fell. Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?

A The factory installed efficient equipment.
B The company used renewable electricity at its main site.
C Production was moved to contractors whose emissions were not included in the company’s total.
D Energy use was tracked monthly.

Argument: A safety manager says a new evacuation plan improved emergency readiness after a successful drill. Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?

A The drill included a headcount at the assembly point.
B Staff received a written route map.
C The alarm system was used during the exercise.
D Participants knew the drill date and used the only open exit, unlike the blocked-exit scenario the plan must handle.

Argument: A procurement office says a new oversight process lowered project costs. Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?

A Projects after the change used a smaller scope and fewer required deliverables than earlier projects.
B The office documented each review step.
C Several bids were received for each project.
D The new process included conflict-of-interest checks.

Argument: A utility says an optional peak-use program reduced household electricity consumption. Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?

A Participants received time-of-use information.
B Households that enrolled had already used less electricity than nonparticipants before the program.
C The program sent peak-period notices.
D Meters recorded daily consumption.

Argument: A school says its new practice exam improved student learning because scores on the final rose. Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?

A Students received feedback on practice answers.
B Teachers held review sessions before the final.
C The final used the same question format repeatedly practiced in the new exam sessions.
D The practice exam covered the same course topics.

Argument: A manufacturer argues that automated inspection reduced defects reaching customers. Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?

A The system checked every standard item.
B The inspection line ran at a steady speed.
C The automated checks were logged.
D The trial removed human review for unusual products, but it did not separately measure defects in those products.

Argument: A town says redevelopment improved neighborhood safety because reported crime fell. Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?

A Residents reported that fear of retaliation led them to stop reporting several kinds of incidents.
B The project added streetlights.
C The town repaired sidewalks.
D Crime reports were counted each month.

Argument: A company says a wellness program reduced staff turnover because departures fell after launch. Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?

A Employees could join exercise sessions.
B The launch followed an unusually high-turnover period, and the company did not compare with its normal seasonal rate.
C The program included stress-management materials.
D Managers recorded departure dates.

Argument: A city says new smoke detectors improved early fire detection because alarms sounded sooner. Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?

A The devices were tested before installation.
B The alarms were audible in nearby rooms.
C The analysis excludes buildings where the detectors lost power or failed self-tests.
D Fire crews received notification records.

Argument: A public agency claims that a campaign changed recycling behavior because surveyed residents say they recycle more. Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?

A The campaign gave sorting examples.
B Residents could take home a guide.
C The survey asked about recent behavior.
D The survey was conducted at a recycling event and did not check actual household collection data.

Argument: A city says releasing an open dataset improved accountability because the files were downloaded many times. Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?

A The download total includes automated search crawlers, and no one checked whether people could reproduce the reported results.
B The data dictionary defines each column.
C The dataset is available without a fee.
D The agency posts updated files quarterly.

Argument: Officials say new cooling shelters reduced heat-related illness because emergency visits fell that summer. Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?

A The shelters were open during daytime hours.
B The summer was much cooler than the prior year and had fewer extreme-heat days.
C Residents received directions to the shelters.
D Staff recorded shelter attendance.

Argument: A coastal authority says a sea wall prevented flooding because no homes flooded after construction. Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?

A The wall was built along the shoreline.
B Engineers inspected the wall after installation.
C The period after construction had no storm surge as high as the earlier comparison storm.
D The town logged flood complaints.

Argument: A retailer says carbon labels changed customer choices because labeled products sold more often. Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?

A The labels used a common scale.
B Customers could read them in the aisle.
C The products belonged to the same broad category.
D The labeled products were also placed at eye level while comparable unlabeled products were moved to lower shelves.

Argument: A research team says its automated screening model treats language groups equally because average error rates were similar. Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?

A Applicants with uncertain language records were excluded, and that group had the highest initial rejection rate.
B The model used the same scoring form for each applicant.
C The research team published its scoring rules.
D The assessment was completed in one week.

Argument: An energy operator says battery storage made the grid more reliable because outages fell in the pilot area. Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?

A Batteries were charged during low-demand periods.
B The pilot area also received a new transmission line while the comparison area did not.
C The operator recorded outage duration.
D The storage system was monitored remotely.

Argument: A service agency says a new complaint process resolved cases faster because average resolution time fell. Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?

A The process assigned each case a reference number.
B Customers received confirmation that a complaint was logged.
C The analysis counted only simple cases completed quickly and left complex open cases out of the average.
D Staff could see case status online.

Argument: A city says a new public-safety camera system reduced incidents because incident reports declined in monitored areas. Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?

A The cameras recorded continuously.
B Operators reviewed footage when a report was made.
C The monitored areas were mapped in advance.
D Camera installation coincided with fewer patrol shifts and a change to the incident-reporting form.