Argument: A health network argues that telehealth reduced clinic waiting times because average waiting time fell after remote visits were introduced.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The service offered video visits on weekdays.
B Some patients completed visits from home.
C The network used the same waiting-room clocks.
D The average excludes patients who could not connect and later attended in person, many of whom waited longest.
Answer: D. The average excludes patients who could not connect and later attended in person, many of whom waited longest.. Excluding the patients who faced access problems could make the average fall without reducing waits for everyone.
Argument: A company argues that an automated hiring screen cut costs without excluding qualified applicants.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The review measured recruiter time but did not track qualified applicants rejected by the screen.
B The tool processed applications overnight.
C Recruiters received a list of recommended applicants.
D The software was updated during the trial.
Answer: A. The review measured recruiter time but did not track qualified applicants rejected by the screen.. Without tracking qualified people screened out, the claim about fair selection is unsupported.
Argument: A city argues that a new flood barrier protects the district because no buildings flooded after it was built.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The barrier is inspected each year.
B No storm during the observation period produced water levels near the barrier’s design limit.
C Residents received a map of the protected area.
D The city recorded building damage after storms.
Answer: B. No storm during the observation period produced water levels near the barrier’s design limit.. The barrier has not been tested under the conditions it was designed to handle.
Argument: A transit authority argues that its new fare policy improved access because average trips per rider increased.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The payment system accepted contactless cards.
B The agency published the new fare table.
C The analysis excludes riders who stopped traveling because the new fares were unaffordable.
D Some frequent riders made additional trips.
Answer: C. The analysis excludes riders who stopped traveling because the new fares were unaffordable.. Average trips among remaining riders can rise even while access worsens for people priced out.
Argument: A regional plan claims that a new express route improved access across the region because average travel time fell.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The route includes fewer stops in the city center.
B Some commuters reached downtown faster.
C The schedule is available online.
D The calculation averages urban trips, while travel time for remote villages increased substantially.
Answer: D. The calculation averages urban trips, while travel time for remote villages increased substantially.. The regional average hides worse access for remote residents, who are included in the claim.
Argument: A company says employees support a restructuring because most survey respondents approved it.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A A large share of employees did not respond, and the company did not compare their views with respondents.
B The survey allowed anonymous responses.
C Employees could add comments.
D The survey was open for two weeks.
Answer: A. A large share of employees did not respond, and the company did not compare their views with respondents.. The views of many nonrespondents may differ, so respondent results may not represent all employees.
Argument: A software firm says its update reduced security incidents because fewer alerts were recorded.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The update included a security patch.
B The update also disabled one monitoring rule that had generated many of the alerts.
C The firm kept a release log.
D The software was installed on the same servers.
Answer: B. The update also disabled one monitoring rule that had generated many of the alerts.. Fewer alerts may reflect reduced detection rather than fewer security incidents.
Argument: A manufacturer says its climate plan lowered total emissions because its own factory emissions fell.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The factory installed efficient equipment.
B The company used renewable electricity at its main site.
C Production was moved to contractors whose emissions were not included in the company’s total.
D Energy use was tracked monthly.
Answer: C. Production was moved to contractors whose emissions were not included in the company’s total.. Outsourcing production may shift emissions outside the measured boundary instead of reducing them overall.
Argument: A safety manager says a new evacuation plan improved emergency readiness after a successful drill.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The drill included a headcount at the assembly point.
B Staff received a written route map.
C The alarm system was used during the exercise.
D Participants knew the drill date and used the only open exit, unlike the blocked-exit scenario the plan must handle.
Answer: D. Participants knew the drill date and used the only open exit, unlike the blocked-exit scenario the plan must handle.. The drill did not test an important foreseeable obstacle, limiting what it shows about readiness.
Argument: A procurement office says a new oversight process lowered project costs.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Projects after the change used a smaller scope and fewer required deliverables than earlier projects.
B The office documented each review step.
C Several bids were received for each project.
D The new process included conflict-of-interest checks.
Answer: A. Projects after the change used a smaller scope and fewer required deliverables than earlier projects.. Lower costs may simply reflect less work, so the projects are not comparable.
Argument: A utility says an optional peak-use program reduced household electricity consumption.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Participants received time-of-use information.
B Households that enrolled had already used less electricity than nonparticipants before the program.
C The program sent peak-period notices.
D Meters recorded daily consumption.
Answer: B. Households that enrolled had already used less electricity than nonparticipants before the program.. Lower use may reflect self-selection by households already inclined to conserve.
Argument: A school says its new practice exam improved student learning because scores on the final rose.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Students received feedback on practice answers.
B Teachers held review sessions before the final.
C The final used the same question format repeatedly practiced in the new exam sessions.
D The practice exam covered the same course topics.
Answer: C. The final used the same question format repeatedly practiced in the new exam sessions.. Higher scores may reflect familiarity with the test format rather than broader learning.
Argument: A manufacturer argues that automated inspection reduced defects reaching customers.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The system checked every standard item.
B The inspection line ran at a steady speed.
C The automated checks were logged.
D The trial removed human review for unusual products, but it did not separately measure defects in those products.
Answer: D. The trial removed human review for unusual products, but it did not separately measure defects in those products.. A possible risk group was excluded from measurement, so the total defect claim is incomplete.
Argument: A town says redevelopment improved neighborhood safety because reported crime fell.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Residents reported that fear of retaliation led them to stop reporting several kinds of incidents.
B The project added streetlights.
C The town repaired sidewalks.
D Crime reports were counted each month.
Answer: A. Residents reported that fear of retaliation led them to stop reporting several kinds of incidents.. Fewer reports may indicate underreporting rather than fewer crimes.
Argument: A company says a wellness program reduced staff turnover because departures fell after launch.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Employees could join exercise sessions.
B The launch followed an unusually high-turnover period, and the company did not compare with its normal seasonal rate.
C The program included stress-management materials.
D Managers recorded departure dates.
Answer: B. The launch followed an unusually high-turnover period, and the company did not compare with its normal seasonal rate.. Turnover might have fallen naturally after an unusually high period even without the program.
Argument: A city says new smoke detectors improved early fire detection because alarms sounded sooner.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The devices were tested before installation.
B The alarms were audible in nearby rooms.
C The analysis excludes buildings where the detectors lost power or failed self-tests.
D Fire crews received notification records.
Answer: C. The analysis excludes buildings where the detectors lost power or failed self-tests.. Excluding failed devices may overstate how reliably the system detects fires across all buildings.
Argument: A public agency claims that a campaign changed recycling behavior because surveyed residents say they recycle more.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The campaign gave sorting examples.
B Residents could take home a guide.
C The survey asked about recent behavior.
D The survey was conducted at a recycling event and did not check actual household collection data.
Answer: D. The survey was conducted at a recycling event and did not check actual household collection data.. Event attendees may be especially interested in recycling, and self-reports were not verified.
Argument: A city says releasing an open dataset improved accountability because the files were downloaded many times.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The download total includes automated search crawlers, and no one checked whether people could reproduce the reported results.
B The data dictionary defines each column.
C The dataset is available without a fee.
D The agency posts updated files quarterly.
Answer: A. The download total includes automated search crawlers, and no one checked whether people could reproduce the reported results.. Downloads alone do not establish that people used the data to verify decisions.
Argument: Officials say new cooling shelters reduced heat-related illness because emergency visits fell that summer.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The shelters were open during daytime hours.
B The summer was much cooler than the prior year and had fewer extreme-heat days.
C Residents received directions to the shelters.
D Staff recorded shelter attendance.
Answer: B. The summer was much cooler than the prior year and had fewer extreme-heat days.. Milder weather is an alternative explanation for fewer heat-related visits.
Argument: A coastal authority says a sea wall prevented flooding because no homes flooded after construction.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The wall was built along the shoreline.
B Engineers inspected the wall after installation.
C The period after construction had no storm surge as high as the earlier comparison storm.
D The town logged flood complaints.
Answer: C. The period after construction had no storm surge as high as the earlier comparison storm.. The wall has not been exposed to a comparable surge, so the before-and-after result is inconclusive.
Argument: A retailer says carbon labels changed customer choices because labeled products sold more often.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The labels used a common scale.
B Customers could read them in the aisle.
C The products belonged to the same broad category.
D The labeled products were also placed at eye level while comparable unlabeled products were moved to lower shelves.
Answer: D. The labeled products were also placed at eye level while comparable unlabeled products were moved to lower shelves.. Shelf placement could explain the sales difference independently of the labels.
Argument: A research team says its automated screening model treats language groups equally because average error rates were similar.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Applicants with uncertain language records were excluded, and that group had the highest initial rejection rate.
B The model used the same scoring form for each applicant.
C The research team published its scoring rules.
D The assessment was completed in one week.
Answer: A. Applicants with uncertain language records were excluded, and that group had the highest initial rejection rate.. Excluding a group with high rejection rates can conceal unequal performance.
Argument: An energy operator says battery storage made the grid more reliable because outages fell in the pilot area.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Batteries were charged during low-demand periods.
B The pilot area also received a new transmission line while the comparison area did not.
C The operator recorded outage duration.
D The storage system was monitored remotely.
Answer: B. The pilot area also received a new transmission line while the comparison area did not.. The new transmission line is another intervention that could explain fewer outages.
Argument: A service agency says a new complaint process resolved cases faster because average resolution time fell.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The process assigned each case a reference number.
B Customers received confirmation that a complaint was logged.
C The analysis counted only simple cases completed quickly and left complex open cases out of the average.
D Staff could see case status online.
Answer: C. The analysis counted only simple cases completed quickly and left complex open cases out of the average.. Leaving complex unresolved cases out makes the average unrepresentative of the service’s full caseload.
Argument: A city says a new public-safety camera system reduced incidents because incident reports declined in monitored areas.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The cameras recorded continuously.
B Operators reviewed footage when a report was made.
C The monitored areas were mapped in advance.
D Camera installation coincided with fewer patrol shifts and a change to the incident-reporting form.
Answer: D. Camera installation coincided with fewer patrol shifts and a change to the incident-reporting form.. Changes in patrol coverage and reporting make the decline difficult to attribute to cameras.