Argument: A transit agency says its revised timetable reduced late arrivals at the central station.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The agency printed the timetable on blue paper.
B On-time arrivals improved during the same hours when the revised timetable was operating.
C The station has several platforms.
D Some passengers carry watches.
Answer: B. On-time arrivals improved during the same hours when the revised timetable was operating.. The measure directly records the outcome the revised timetable was intended to improve.
Argument: A clinic says text reminders reduced missed appointments.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The clinic changed the color of its waiting-room walls.
B Patients may bring a book to appointments.
C Appointment data show fewer no-shows among patients who received reminders than in a comparable earlier period.
D The reminder messages used short sentences.
Answer: C. Appointment data show fewer no-shows among patients who received reminders than in a comparable earlier period.. A measured decline in no-shows among recipients supports the claim.
Argument: A school says its new lunch menu is more acceptable to students.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The lunch trays are stored in a different cabinet.
B The cafeteria has a clock near the entrance.
C Some students bring lunch from home.
D A follow-up survey found that more students chose school lunch and rated the new options favorably.
Answer: D. A follow-up survey found that more students chose school lunch and rated the new options favorably.. More students choosing and favoring the menu is evidence of acceptability.
Argument: A town says its rain gardens reduce runoff onto nearby streets.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A During storms of similar rainfall, streets beside the gardens had less standing water than before installation.
B The gardens contain several flower species.
C The street signs were repainted last year.
D Some residents walk beside the gardens.
Answer: A. During storms of similar rainfall, streets beside the gardens had less standing water than before installation.. Comparable storms with less standing water support the runoff-reduction claim.
Argument: A utility says home insulation upgrades reduced heating demand.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The homes have different front-door colors.
B Weather-adjusted energy use fell in upgraded homes, while similar homes without upgrades showed little change.
C The utility mailed bills in smaller envelopes.
D Some residents use electric kettles.
Answer: B. Weather-adjusted energy use fell in upgraded homes, while similar homes without upgrades showed little change.. A comparison group and weather adjustment make the evidence more persuasive.
Argument: A company says a training course reduced data-entry errors.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The training room has a large screen.
B The course certificate uses the company logo.
C Error rates fell more in trained teams than in similar teams that had not yet taken the course.
D Employees received notebooks at the session.
Answer: C. Error rates fell more in trained teams than in similar teams that had not yet taken the course.. The comparison with similar untrained teams supports a training effect.
Argument: A city says its bus lane shortened bus journeys.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The lane markings use a new shade of paint.
B The buses have route numbers on their front.
C Some passengers read newspapers during trips.
D Average bus travel time fell on the lane after launch, with passenger volume and observation times held comparable.
Answer: D. Average bus travel time fell on the lane after launch, with passenger volume and observation times held comparable.. The measured travel-time change under comparable conditions supports the claim.
Argument: A public website says translated pages helped more residents complete applications.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Completion rates rose among users who selected the translated versions, with the form and eligibility rules unchanged.
B The website banner uses larger letters.
C The agency also has a telephone line.
D Some applicants use desktop computers.
Answer: A. Completion rates rose among users who selected the translated versions, with the form and eligibility rules unchanged.. Higher completion among users of the translations supports their usefulness.
Argument: A school says a device-lending program improved assignment completion for students without home computers.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The tablets came in protective cases.
B Completion increased among borrowing students, while their course requirements and teacher deadlines stayed the same.
C Students have different favorite subjects.
D The library stocks printed dictionaries.
Answer: B. Completion increased among borrowing students, while their course requirements and teacher deadlines stayed the same.. Improvement among the target students while requirements stayed constant is supportive evidence.
Argument: A road-safety team says a redesigned junction reduced collisions.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The new road signs are reflective.
B The junction has a bakery nearby.
C Collision rates fell at the junction while comparable nearby junctions had no similar change.
D Several drivers use navigation apps.
Answer: C. Collision rates fell at the junction while comparable nearby junctions had no similar change.. The comparison junctions help rule out a wider trend as the explanation.
Argument: A library says its weekend opening hours improved access for working residents.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The library bought new chairs.
B A nearby café changed its menu.
C Many library books have colorful covers.
D Weekend visits rose most among residents whose work schedules made weekday visits difficult.
Answer: D. Weekend visits rose most among residents whose work schedules made weekday visits difficult.. The increased use by the group the change targeted supports the access claim.
Argument: A building manager says smoke detectors improved early fire response.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Records show that alarms alerted occupants sooner in buildings with working detectors than in similar buildings without them.
B The detectors are white.
C The buildings have different floor plans.
D Fire crews use radios.
Answer: A. Records show that alarms alerted occupants sooner in buildings with working detectors than in similar buildings without them.. Earlier alerts in comparable buildings are directly relevant to early response.
Argument: A company says flexible start times improved employee retention.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The office added a coffee machine.
B Comparable teams offered flexible starts had fewer voluntary departures over the same review period.
C Employees use different desk chairs.
D The company changed its letterhead.
Answer: B. Comparable teams offered flexible starts had fewer voluntary departures over the same review period.. Lower departures in teams receiving the change support the retention claim.
Argument: A college says new covered bicycle parking encouraged cycling.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The rack roof is made of metal.
B The college has a science building.
C Bike counts rose at the covered racks after installation while class attendance remained similar.
D Some students own helmets.
Answer: C. Bike counts rose at the covered racks after installation while class attendance remained similar.. Higher bike counts with similar attendance are evidence that the parking may have encouraged cycling.
Argument: A town says reusable bottles at its events reduced waste.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Reusable bottles came in several colors.
B The event stage was moved.
C Some visitors brought backpacks.
D The measured weight of disposable bottles in event rubbish fell while attendance stayed about the same.
Answer: D. The measured weight of disposable bottles in event rubbish fell while attendance stayed about the same.. Less disposable-bottle waste at similar attendance supports the claim.
Argument: A school says its mentoring program improved attendance.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Attendance rose for students who participated, compared with similar students who were eligible but had not yet joined.
B Mentors met in a room with posters.
C The school added a new sports team.
D Some participants prefer morning meetings.
Answer: A. Attendance rose for students who participated, compared with similar students who were eligible but had not yet joined.. The comparison with similar eligible students strengthens the program claim.
Argument: A neighborhood group says its market improved access to fresh food.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The market sells reusable bags.
B Most surveyed market customers came from nearby areas that previously had no fresh-food retailer within walking distance.
C Some vendors accept cash.
D The stalls use striped awnings.
Answer: B. Most surveyed market customers came from nearby areas that previously had no fresh-food retailer within walking distance.. The customer origins show that the market reached the underserved area named in the claim.
Argument: A park service says shaded play areas reduced heat-related problems.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The playground equipment is brightly colored.
B The park has several benches.
C During equally hot periods, first-aid reports from shaded play areas fell compared with nearby unshaded areas.
D Children use different games.
Answer: C. During equally hot periods, first-aid reports from shaded play areas fell compared with nearby unshaded areas.. The comparison under similar heat conditions supports a protective effect of shade.
Argument: A city says solar streetlights improved lighting reliability in a remote area.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The solar panels face south.
B The poles are painted gray.
C The area has a walking trail.
D The solar lights stayed on during grid outages when the older grid-powered lights went dark.
Answer: D. The solar lights stayed on during grid outages when the older grid-powered lights went dark.. Continued operation during grid outages directly supports reliability.
Argument: A clinic says evening appointments reduced waiting times for working patients.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Wait times fell for the evening sessions without reducing the number of appointments offered in daytime sessions.
B The clinic has a new waiting-room clock.
C The appointment cards use a different font.
D Some patients arrive by bicycle.
Answer: A. Wait times fell for the evening sessions without reducing the number of appointments offered in daytime sessions.. The result shows shorter waits without simply removing existing appointment capacity.
Argument: A food-labeling project says clear sugar labels helped shoppers choose lower-sugar products.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The labels were printed on recyclable paper.
B In a trial, shoppers shown the labels selected lower-sugar versions more often than shoppers shown the same shelves without labels.
C The products were arranged alphabetically.
D Shoppers used baskets rather than carts.
Answer: B. In a trial, shoppers shown the labels selected lower-sugar versions more often than shoppers shown the same shelves without labels.. The controlled comparison directly links label visibility with the choices.
Argument: An engineering team says shared code-review tools shortened software delivery time.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The tool’s icon is blue.
B The engineers use different keyboards.
C Projects using the tools finished review faster than comparable projects with similar scope and staffing.
D The project names contain numbers.
Answer: C. Projects using the tools finished review faster than comparable projects with similar scope and staffing.. Comparable projects make the faster review evidence relevant to the tool’s effect.
Argument: Residents say a new freight route reduced nighttime truck noise on their street.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The route passes an industrial district.
B The street has a bus stop.
C Some residents keep windows closed.
D Noise measurements fell there after the route changed while truck counts on the new route increased.
Answer: D. Noise measurements fell there after the route changed while truck counts on the new route increased.. The measurements and increased use of the alternate route support the stated effect.
Argument: A city says a new pedestrian crossing improved safety for schoolchildren.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Near-miss reports fell at the crossing during school arrival times after it opened.
B The crossing is painted with bright stripes.
C The school has a playground.
D Some children walk with friends.
Answer: A. Near-miss reports fell at the crossing during school arrival times after it opened.. The reduction in relevant near-miss reports is evidence of a safety improvement.
Argument: A water authority says leak alerts helped households reduce water loss.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The alert letter used a window envelope.
B After receiving an alert, households repaired confirmed leaks and their meter readings fell compared with the prior month.
C Some households have gardens.
D The water meters are located outdoors.
Answer: B. After receiving an alert, households repaired confirmed leaks and their meter readings fell compared with the prior month.. Repairs followed the alerts and measured consumption fell, supporting the claim.