Argument: A utility says a smart thermostat cut heating use because average bills fell after it was installed.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The thermostat was connected to home Wi-Fi.
B Users could set a weekly schedule.
C The comparison did not adjust for a warmer winter, which also reduced heating demand.
D The utility sent instructions with each device.
Answer: C. The comparison did not adjust for a warmer winter, which also reduced heating demand.. A warmer winter is an alternative explanation for lower heating use.
Argument: A delivery company says a new routing system reduced average delivery time.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The system displayed traffic conditions.
B Drivers received route instructions on a screen.
C The average was calculated from completed deliveries.
D The calculation excluded orders that were canceled after being delayed.
Answer: D. The calculation excluded orders that were canceled after being delayed.. Excluding the most delayed canceled orders could make the average look better without improving service.
Argument: Officials say a redesigned junction reduced crash risk because recorded crashes fell.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Traffic counts also fell sharply after a major employer nearby closed.
B The junction received clearer lane markings.
C Drivers were told about the new layout.
D The road surface was repaired.
Answer: A. Traffic counts also fell sharply after a major employer nearby closed.. Lower traffic exposure could account for fewer crashes even if the junction became no safer.
Argument: A college concludes that its online course improves exam performance because enrolled students scored higher.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The course included weekly practice questions.
B Enrollment was voluntary, and students who chose the course had stronger prior grades.
C Students could replay recorded lessons.
D The final exam covered the announced syllabus.
Answer: B. Enrollment was voluntary, and students who chose the course had stronger prior grades.. The participantsβ stronger starting performance could explain the score difference.
Argument: A youth organization says its social-media campaign reached local teenagers because its posts received many likes.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The posts used short videos.
B The campaign was shared several times.
C Most accounts liking the posts were located outside the region and many were automated accounts.
D Teenagers could comment on the posts.
Answer: C. Most accounts liking the posts were located outside the region and many were automated accounts.. Likes from outside the target audience do not show that local teenagers were reached.
Argument: A school says a new attendance program reduced absences.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Staff called families after repeated absences.
B Students received attendance reminders.
C The program was introduced at the start of term.
D The school changed its rules so late arrivals were no longer recorded as absent.
Answer: D. The school changed its rules so late arrivals were no longer recorded as absent.. A recording-rule change can lower the absence count without changing attendance.
Argument: A company says its new hiring method selected stronger candidates because recent hires scored higher in interviews.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The interview scoring rubric was made easier to score highly at the same time.
B The company trained interviewers to use the new method.
C Applicants completed the same job task.
D Hiring records include interview scores.
Answer: A. The interview scoring rubric was made easier to score highly at the same time.. A more generous scoring rubric can explain higher scores without stronger candidates.
Argument: A hospital says an air purifier reduced asthma symptoms among patients in its waiting area.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The purifier was installed near the seating area.
B Local pollen levels dropped substantially during the same weeks.
C Staff changed the filter on schedule.
D Patients remained in the waiting area for similar lengths of time.
Answer: B. Local pollen levels dropped substantially during the same weeks.. A decrease in pollen could explain fewer symptoms independently of the purifier.
Argument: A water authority says a conservation campaign reduced household use because billed consumption fell.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The campaign included leak-check instructions.
B Residents received monthly conservation tips.
C The authority replaced measured meter readings with lower default estimates for many homes.
D The billing period lasted the same number of days.
Answer: C. The authority replaced measured meter readings with lower default estimates for many homes.. Estimated bills are not comparable with measured consumption and may create an apparent decline.
Argument: An engineering manager says a new workflow made projects faster because one team finished early.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The workflow included a shared task board.
B The team held a short daily check-in.
C The project dates were recorded.
D That team was assigned simpler projects than the teams used for comparison.
Answer: D. That team was assigned simpler projects than the teams used for comparison.. Differences in project difficulty could explain the faster completion.
Argument: A council says residents broadly support a proposed road because most survey respondents favored it.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The survey was sent only to members of a group that had publicly supported the road.
B The survey asked respondents to state a preference.
C The proposed road map was attached.
D Responses were collected online.
Answer: A. The survey was sent only to members of a group that had publicly supported the road.. The selected group is not representative of residents, so the result cannot establish broad support.
Argument: A retailer says its new packaging reduced product returns.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The package uses a stronger outer layer.
B The return window was shortened from 30 days to 7 days at the same time.
C Customers received instructions on opening it.
D The retailer tracked return counts.
Answer: B. The return window was shortened from 30 days to 7 days at the same time.. A shorter return window could reduce recorded returns even if the packaging did not improve.
Argument: A city says its housing policy reduced homelessness because fewer people were counted in shelters.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The policy funded additional rental units.
B Some families received housing assistance.
C The count excluded people sleeping outdoors and shelters that had closed.
D The shelter count was taken in winter.
Answer: C. The count excluded people sleeping outdoors and shelters that had closed.. A shelter-only count can fall even when homelessness outside shelters rises or goes unmeasured.
Argument: A manufacturer says new software reduced production errors because fewer defects appeared in its monthly report.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The software checks entries as workers submit them.
B The system flags duplicate part numbers.
C The report was issued on the same date each month.
D The company stopped recording minor defects that were previously included.
Answer: D. The company stopped recording minor defects that were previously included.. Changing what counts as a recorded defect can explain the apparent reduction.
Argument: A construction firm says sound barriers reduced neighborhood noise complaints.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The city removed the public complaint hotline during the construction period.
B The barriers were installed beside the loudest work area.
C Noise measurements were taken nearby.
D The barriers were checked after storms.
Answer: A. The city removed the public complaint hotline during the construction period.. Fewer reports may reflect reduced ability to complain, not lower noise.
Argument: A clinic says a new prevention program lowered local infection rates.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The program included hygiene information.
B The number of diagnostic tests fell, and the rate was calculated only from confirmed cases.
C Clinic staff distributed the materials locally.
D The infection-rate calculation used the same calendar months.
Answer: B. The number of diagnostic tests fell, and the rate was calculated only from confirmed cases.. Fewer tests can reduce confirmed cases and distort the reported rate.
Argument: A school says a building renovation improved student learning because exam scores increased.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The renovation added quiet study rooms.
B The school kept the same teaching staff.
C The education authority replaced the exam with a substantially easier version that year.
D Students used the new rooms during study periods.
Answer: C. The education authority replaced the exam with a substantially easier version that year.. An easier exam could account for higher scores without improved learning.
Argument: A market says its new stall arrangement made fresh food more affordable.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The stalls were grouped by food type.
B Customers could compare prices more easily.
C The new arrangement left walkways clear.
D A temporary subsidy paid part of the listed price during the trial.
Answer: D. A temporary subsidy paid part of the listed price during the trial.. The subsidy, rather than the stall layout, could explain lower prices paid.
Argument: An energy operator says new wind turbines improved grid stability because there were fewer outages.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The comparison period had unusually mild weather and much lower electricity demand.
B The turbines supplied electricity during windy periods.
C The operator connected them to the grid.
D Outages were logged by the same control center.
Answer: A. The comparison period had unusually mild weather and much lower electricity demand.. Milder weather and lower demand could explain fewer outages without a turbine effect.
Argument: A factory says predictive maintenance reduced equipment downtime.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The system monitored machine vibration.
B The factory changed its definition so planned stoppages were no longer counted as downtime.
C Technicians received maintenance alerts.
D The factory recorded machine status each shift.
Answer: B. The factory changed its definition so planned stoppages were no longer counted as downtime.. A changed downtime definition can produce a lower figure without more reliable equipment.
Argument: A company says remote work increased productivity because output per employee rose.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Employees used online collaboration tools.
B Several teams worked from home.
C The company laid off support staff and counted only remaining employees in the calculation.
D Managers recorded completed projects.
Answer: C. The company laid off support staff and counted only remaining employees in the calculation.. Removing support roles from the denominator can raise output per employee without increasing total productivity.
Argument: A transit agency says a schedule change improved on-time performance.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The agency revised departure times.
B Passengers could see the updated schedule.
C Drivers received route briefings.
D It canceled several trips that were most likely to run late before measuring punctuality.
Answer: D. It canceled several trips that were most likely to run late before measuring punctuality.. Removing difficult trips from the measure could improve the percentage without improving service overall.
Argument: A building owner says occupancy sensors reduced electricity use.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The building had fewer occupants during the comparison period.
B Sensors switched off lights in empty rooms.
C The system recorded light usage.
D The sensors covered most meeting rooms.
Answer: A. The building had fewer occupants during the comparison period.. Lower occupancy could reduce electricity use even without the sensors.
Argument: A company says its new hiring score reduced bias because selection rates became similar across groups.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The score was applied to each application.
B The company removed several qualified applicant groups from the pool before calculating the rates.
C Recruiters received a written scoring guide.
D The company reviewed hiring records monthly.
Answer: B. The company removed several qualified applicant groups from the pool before calculating the rates.. Excluding applicants from the analysis can make rates appear more equal without reducing bias.
Argument: A city says it met its recycling target because the total weight of recycled material increased.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Collection trucks visited on the published schedule.
B Residents received sorting guides.
C The total included rubble from a one-time road demolition that was not part of household recycling.
D The recycling facility weighed incoming loads.
Answer: C. The total included rubble from a one-time road demolition that was not part of household recycling.. The increase may come from construction rubble rather than improved household recycling.