Argument: A café’s profit rose after it introduced breakfast service, so the owner concludes that breakfast caused the increase.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A A large office opened next door during the same week.
B Many customers ordered breakfast items on their visits.
C The café kept its prices and opening hours unchanged.
D Breakfast sales rose during the period.
Answer: A. A large office opened next door during the same week.. The new office could have brought extra customers independently of the breakfast service.
Argument: A school introduced a reminder app and attendance improved, so the principal says the app improved attendance.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The app displayed each student’s timetable.
B The bus company added an early route at the start of the same term.
C Teachers continued taking attendance in the usual way.
D Students received reminders the evening before class.
Answer: B. The bus company added an early route at the start of the same term.. The new bus route is an alternative reason students could arrive more reliably.
Argument: A library extended evening hours and visitor counts increased, so the director credits the longer hours.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Some visitors used the study desks after 6 p.m.
B The library kept the same book collection.
C The extension began during the exam period, when students usually visit more often.
D The new hours were announced on its website.
Answer: C. The extension began during the exam period, when students usually visit more often.. Exam season could explain the higher visitor count even without the schedule change.
Argument: A park installed new lights and evening visits rose, so the council says the lights attracted more visitors.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Several visitors said the path felt easier to use after dark.
B The lights covered the previously dim sections.
C The park remained open at the same times.
D A week-long festival nearby also began when the lights were installed.
Answer: D. A week-long festival nearby also began when the lights were installed.. The nearby festival offers another likely reason for the increase in evening visitors.
Argument: A shop displayed a sale sign and weekly sales increased, so the manager concludes that the sign caused the increase.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A A competing shop closed for renovations during that week.
B More shoppers noticed the sale sign.
C The shop sold the advertised items at a reduced price.
D The manager placed the sign beside the entrance.
Answer: A. A competing shop closed for renovations during that week.. The competitor’s closure could have redirected shoppers to this store.
Argument: A new bus route was added and ridership on the route grew, so officials say it created new public-transport use.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Passengers used the route to reach several neighborhoods.
B The nearby train line was closed for maintenance during the same period.
C The bus ran on the published schedule.
D The route had stops near shops and schools.
Answer: B. The nearby train line was closed for maintenance during the same period.. Some riders may have switched from the closed train rather than becoming new transit users.
Argument: Students who attended tutoring earned higher test scores, so the school concludes that tutoring raised their scores.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Tutors reviewed the course material with students.
B Students attended sessions after school.
C Students who chose tutoring had higher scores before tutoring began.
D The tutoring covered topics on the exam.
Answer: C. Students who chose tutoring had higher scores before tutoring began.. The score difference may reflect students’ prior achievement rather than a tutoring effect.
Argument: A greenhouse produced a larger vegetable harvest than the farm’s outdoor plot, so the farmer concludes that the greenhouse caused the difference.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The greenhouse recorded more growing days.
B Workers checked the plants regularly.
C The harvest was weighed at the end of the season.
D The greenhouse plot used a different crop variety and received more fertilizer.
Answer: D. The greenhouse plot used a different crop variety and received more fertilizer.. Different varieties and fertilizer make it impossible to attribute the entire yield difference to the greenhouse.
Argument: A company adopted remote work and sick-day absences fell, so managers say remote work reduced illness.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The region had a much milder flu season that year.
B Employees used video meetings to coordinate work.
C The company recorded sick days in the same way.
D Most teams worked remotely several days each week.
Answer: A. The region had a much milder flu season that year.. A milder flu season could have reduced absences regardless of work location.
Argument: A parking app launched and drivers reported spending less time searching, so the city says the app solved parking delays.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Drivers could see open spaces in the app.
B The city opened two additional parking facilities at the same time.
C The app covered the downtown area.
D Some drivers found a space soon after checking it.
Answer: B. The city opened two additional parking facilities at the same time.. The new facilities could explain shorter searches without the app being the main cause.
Argument: A factory issued protective gloves and hand injuries declined, so the manager concludes that the gloves caused the decline.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Workers had gloves available near each machine.
B The new gloves fit most employees.
C The factory also changed its injury-reporting process, and minor incidents were no longer recorded.
D The safety team showed workers how to use them.
Answer: C. The factory also changed its injury-reporting process, and minor incidents were no longer recorded.. Fewer recorded injuries may reflect a reporting change rather than safer work.
Argument: A farmer used a new fertilizer and harvested more grain, so the farmer concludes that the product increased yield.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The fertilizer was applied at the recommended time.
B The harvest weight was measured in the same way.
C The field had been used for the same crop before.
D Rainfall was much higher during the new fertilizer season than in the comparison season.
Answer: D. Rainfall was much higher during the new fertilizer season than in the comparison season.. The different rainfall could explain some or all of the larger harvest.
Argument: A school printed weekly lesson summaries and exam results improved, so the head teacher credits the summaries.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The school also reduced class sizes that term.
B Students received a summary every Friday.
C The summaries covered the lessons studied that week.
D Teachers continued giving the same syllabus.
Answer: A. The school also reduced class sizes that term.. Smaller classes are another change that could improve results.
Argument: A hotel changed its bedding and online ratings improved, so the manager says the bedding caused better ratings.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Guests mentioned the new bedding in some reviews.
B The hotel completed a full renovation and launched a discount campaign at the same time.
C The hotel continued requesting feedback after each stay.
D The bedding was changed in every room.
Answer: B. The hotel completed a full renovation and launched a discount campaign at the same time.. The renovation and discount campaign could have influenced ratings independently.
Argument: A business replaced its lights with efficient bulbs and its electricity bill fell, so it concludes that the bulbs lowered energy use.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The new bulbs used less power than the old ones.
B The number of bulbs remained the same.
C The business shortened its operating hours during the billing period.
D The electricity rate did not change.
Answer: C. The business shortened its operating hours during the billing period.. Fewer operating hours could account for the lower bill even if the bulbs made little difference.
Argument: A town changed its public clocks and residents became more punctual, so officials credit the new clocks.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Residents could read the new clocks from farther away.
B The clocks showed the same official time.
C The clocks were installed at busy locations.
D The town also changed the start time of several public services.
Answer: D. The town also changed the start time of several public services.. Changing service start times could explain the punctuality change.
Argument: A recycling campaign began and the reported amount recycled rose, so the council says residents recycled more.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The waste company changed its method for recording recyclable material during the same month.
B The campaign explained how to sort items.
C The campaign reached several neighborhoods.
D Residents received collection calendars.
Answer: A. The waste company changed its method for recording recyclable material during the same month.. A changed recording method could raise the reported amount without a change in residents’ behavior.
Argument: A school ran a seat-belt campaign and student injuries in car trips declined, so staff say the campaign caused the decline.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Students saw campaign posters at school.
B Police began enforcing seat-belt rules more often during the same period.
C Parents received a safety leaflet.
D The school repeated the message during assemblies.
Answer: B. Police began enforcing seat-belt rules more often during the same period.. Increased enforcement is another possible cause of improved seat-belt use.
Argument: A park added a drinking fountain and visits increased, so the council says the fountain brought more visitors.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Visitors used the fountain on warm days.
B The fountain was beside the main path.
C The previous summer was unusually hot, while the comparison summer was mild.
D The park’s opening hours stayed the same.
Answer: C. The previous summer was unusually hot, while the comparison summer was mild.. Weather differences could explain changes in park attendance.
Argument: A company introduced a phone help desk and complaints fell, so managers conclude that the service improved customer satisfaction.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Customers could speak with a help-desk agent.
B The new phone number appeared on receipts.
C Agents were trained to answer common questions.
D The company stopped counting complaints made through social media.
Answer: D. The company stopped counting complaints made through social media.. The lower count could result from excluding a complaint channel rather than greater satisfaction.
Argument: An elevator upgrade was completed and waiting times fell, so the building manager credits the upgrade.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A A large tenant moved out, reducing the number of people using the elevators.
B The upgraded elevator moved between floors faster.
C The waiting time was recorded at the same hours.
D The elevator was available on each workday.
Answer: A. A large tenant moved out, reducing the number of people using the elevators.. Fewer building users could explain shorter waits even without the upgrade.
Argument: A shopping app was launched and repeat purchases increased, so the retailer says the app improved loyalty.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Customers could save favorite products in the app.
B The retailer introduced a loyalty discount at the same time.
C The app displayed the same product range as the store.
D Some repeat buyers used the app.
Answer: B. The retailer introduced a loyalty discount at the same time.. The discount could have increased repeat purchases independently of the app.
Argument: A farm installed automatic irrigation and water use fell, so the farmer concludes that the system saved water.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A The system delivered measured amounts to each row.
B The farmer checked the water meter.
C The season had substantially more rainfall than the season used for comparison.
D The irrigation system ran on a schedule.
Answer: C. The season had substantially more rainfall than the season used for comparison.. Higher rainfall could explain the reduction in irrigation water.
Argument: A mentoring program began and student withdrawals declined, so the school says mentoring prevented students from leaving.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A Mentors met students regularly.
B Students could ask mentors for help.
C The program was offered during the school year.
D The school changed how it defines and records a student withdrawal that year.
Answer: D. The school changed how it defines and records a student withdrawal that year.. A recording-definition change could produce a lower withdrawal count without changing retention.
Argument: A city replaced diesel buses and roadside pollution readings fell, so officials say the bus replacement improved air quality.
Question: Which new fact most weakens the argument?
A A major industrial plant near the monitor shut down during the same period.
B The new buses produced less exhaust on their routes.
C The city measured pollution at the same roadside station.
D The replacement fleet operated on the same routes.
Answer: A. A major industrial plant near the monitor shut down during the same period.. The plant closure is a separate change that could have lowered the readings.