Premises: A request receives an access token only if identity is verified. Identity is verified only if the account record matches. Request R received a token.
Conclusions: I. Request R’s account record matched. II. Any matching account record receives an access token.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
D Only Conclusion I follows
Answer: D. Only Conclusion I follows. Token issuance requires verified identity, which in turn requires a matching record; the reverse guarantee is absent.
Premises: If the backup process is incomplete, the service remains unavailable. The service is available.
Conclusions: I. The backup process is complete. II. A complete backup always makes every service available.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Only Conclusion II follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: A. Only Conclusion I follows. Availability rules out an incomplete backup, but a complete backup alone may not address other service faults.
Premises: At least one of Circuit A or Circuit B is active. Circuit A is not active.
Conclusions: I. Circuit B is active. II. Circuit A is not active.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Only Conclusion II follows
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: B. Both Conclusions I and II follow. With at least one active and A inactive, B must be active; A’s status is also explicit.
Premises: Exactly one of Projects X, Y and Z is selected. Neither X nor Y is selected.
Conclusions: I. Project Z is selected. II. Project X is not selected.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Only Conclusion II follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: C. Both Conclusions I and II follow. The exclusive choice leaves Z as the selected project, and X’s non-selection is stated.
Premises: If a report is verified, it can be released. If a report can be released, it is placed in the public catalog.
Conclusions: I. If a report is verified, it is placed in the public catalog. II. If a report is in the public catalog, it was verified.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
D Only Conclusion I follows
Answer: D. Only Conclusion I follows. Verification leads through release to cataloging; cataloging could have occurred under another process.
Premises: Every urgent request is reviewed today. Some requests reviewed today are incomplete.
Conclusions: I. Every urgent request is incomplete. II. Some requests reviewed today are incomplete.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Only Conclusion I follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: A. Only Conclusion II follows. The second conclusion is given; no relation is stated between urgency and incompleteness.
Premises: No temporary pass allows entry after closing. All contractor passes are temporary.
Conclusions: I. No contractor pass allows entry after closing. II. No pass that allows entry after closing is a contractor pass.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Only Conclusion II follows
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: B. Both Conclusions I and II follow. Contractor passes are temporary and therefore cannot allow after-hours entry; the exclusion is symmetric.
Premises: Every member of Group A has passed screening. Every member of Group B has passed screening.
Conclusions: I. Every member of Group A belongs to Group B. II. Every member of Group B belongs to Group A.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Only Conclusion II follows
C Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
D Both Conclusions I and II follow
Answer: C. Neither Conclusion I nor II follows. Passing screening does not establish that either group contains the other.
Premises: If an application is submitted before the deadline, it is accepted for review. Application P was accepted for review.
Conclusions: I. Application P was submitted before the deadline. II. If Application P was not submitted before the deadline, it was not accepted for review.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Only Conclusion II follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: D. Neither Conclusion I nor II follows. Acceptance may have another basis, and the rule does not state what happens to late applications.
Premises: All trained supervisors have access to the control room. Some staff members have control-room access.
Conclusions: I. Every staff member is a trained supervisor. II. Some staff members have control-room access.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Only Conclusion I follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: A. Only Conclusion II follows. The second conclusion is directly given; access alone does not show that all staff are trained supervisors.
Premises: No invoice lacking a purchase order may be paid. Invoice M was paid.
Conclusions: I. Invoice M had a purchase order. II. Invoice M was approved by the finance director.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Only Conclusion I follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: B. Only Conclusion I follows. Payment rules out the missing purchase order; approval by a particular director is not stated.
Premises: A record may be changed only if two authorized reviewers approve it. Record Q was changed.
Conclusions: I. Two authorized reviewers approved Record Q. II. If two reviewers approve a record, it must be changed.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Only Conclusion I follows
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: C. Only Conclusion I follows. The change required two approvals, but approval alone does not require a change.
Premises: If Sensor A or Sensor B fires, the siren sounds. The siren did not sound.
Conclusions: I. Sensor A did not fire. II. Sensor B did not fire.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Only Conclusion II follows
C Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
D Both Conclusions I and II follow
Answer: D. Both Conclusions I and II follow. A quiet siren rules out both triggers; each conclusion follows.
Premises: If a sample was stored at the required temperature, it remains valid for testing. Sample S is not valid.
Conclusions: I. Sample S was not stored at the required temperature. II. Sample S was contaminated.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Only Conclusion II follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: A. Only Conclusion I follows. Invalidity rules out the required storage condition under the rule, but the reason for invalidity is unknown.
Premises: Exactly one of Options A and B is chosen. Option A was chosen.
Conclusions: I. Option B was not chosen. II. Option A was chosen.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Only Conclusion II follows
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: B. Both Conclusions I and II follow. With exactly one chosen and A chosen, B was not chosen; A’s choice is explicit.
Premises: If no response is received by the deadline, the application closes. Application R did not close.
Conclusions: I. A response was received by the deadline. II. Application R was approved.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Only Conclusion I follows
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: C. Only Conclusion I follows. The contrapositive shows that a timely response was received; approval is not implied.
Premises: If a customer pays by card, a receipt is generated. A receipt was generated.
Conclusions: I. The customer paid by card. II. If the customer did not pay by card, no receipt is generated.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Only Conclusion II follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: D. Neither Conclusion I nor II follows. A receipt could be generated for other payment methods, so neither converse follows.
Premises: An inspection is complete only if all required documents are present. All required documents are present.
Conclusions: I. The inspection is complete. II. If the inspection is complete, all required documents are present.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Only Conclusion I follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: A. Only Conclusion II follows. Complete documents are necessary but not sufficient; the second conclusion states the rule.
Premises: In a league of five teams, every team plays each other team exactly once.
Conclusions: I. Each team plays four matches. II. If a team played four matches, it must have won at least one.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Only Conclusion I follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: B. Only Conclusion I follows. Each team faces the other four teams; the number of matches says nothing about wins.
Premises: A project advances if and only if its manager signs the release. The project advanced.
Conclusions: I. The manager signed the release. II. If the manager signed the release, the project advances.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Only Conclusion II follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: C. Both Conclusions I and II follow. The two-way rule makes advancement and signing equivalent, so both conclusions follow.
Premises: No parcel with a missing seal enters the secure room. Parcel K entered the secure room.
Conclusions: I. Parcel K had a seal. II. Parcel K contained fragile goods.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
D Only Conclusion I follows
Answer: D. Only Conclusion I follows. Entry rules out a missing seal; the parcel’s contents are not described.
Premises: The code is valid if and only if its checksum matches. Code C has a matching checksum.
Conclusions: I. Code C is valid. II. If Code C is valid, its checksum matches.
A Both Conclusions I and II follow
B Only Conclusion I follows
C Only Conclusion II follows
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: A. Both Conclusions I and II follow. The biconditional gives both directions, so the matching checksum establishes validity and validity requires the match.
Premises: Exactly two of Tasks A, B and C are selected. Task A is not selected. Task B is selected.
Conclusions: I. Task C is selected. II. Task A is not selected.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Only Conclusion II follows
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: B. Both Conclusions I and II follow. With A excluded and B selected, C must be selected to make exactly two; A’s status is also given.
Premises: If any reviewer rejects a proposal, it is returned for revision. The proposal was not returned.
Conclusions: I. No reviewer rejected the proposal. II. The proposal was approved.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Only Conclusion I follows
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: C. Only Conclusion I follows. No return rules out a rejection under the stated condition; absence of rejection does not prove approval.
Premises: Some staff can use the analysis tool. Everyone who uses the tool has completed training. No untrained person has system access.
Conclusions: I. Some staff members have completed training. II. Some staff members have system access.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
D Only Conclusion I follows
Answer: D. Only Conclusion I follows. The tool-using staff completed training; training alone does not prove that they have system access.