Premises: If a data file passes validation, it is released. If it is released, it is indexed.
Conclusions: I. If the file passes validation, it is indexed. II. If the file is indexed, it must have passed validation.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Only Conclusion I follows
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: C. Only Conclusion I follows. Passing validation leads through release to indexing; indexing could also occur through another route.
Premises: Every coastal parcel is mapped. Some mapped parcels are privately owned.
Conclusions: I. Some coastal parcels are privately owned. II. Some mapped parcels are privately owned.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
D Only Conclusion II follows
Answer: D. Only Conclusion II follows. The second conclusion is given; the premises do not establish that the privately owned mapped parcels are coastal.
Premises: No encrypted message is visible without a key. Some alerts are encrypted messages.
Conclusions: I. Some alerts are not visible without a key. II. No alert is visible without a key.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Only Conclusion II follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: A. Only Conclusion I follows. The encrypted alerts are not visible without a key, but the premise does not classify every alert as encrypted.
Premises: If a permit is valid, the inspection is current. If the inspection is current, the site may operate. The site may not operate.
Conclusions: I. The inspection is not current. II. The permit is not valid.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Only Conclusion II follows
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: B. Both Conclusions I and II follow. If the site cannot operate, the inspection is not current; that in turn rules out a valid permit.
Premises: Exactly one of Test A or Test B passed. Test A did not pass.
Conclusions: I. Test B passed. II. Test A did not pass.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Only Conclusion II follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: C. Both Conclusions I and II follow. The exclusive choice requires Test B to pass, and Test Aβs failure is stated.
Premises: At least one of the two backup pumps is defective. Pump A is not defective.
Conclusions: I. Pump B is defective. II. Pump A is not defective.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Only Conclusion II follows
C Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
D Both Conclusions I and II follow
Answer: D. Both Conclusions I and II follow. If at least one is defective and A is not, B must be defective; both conclusions follow.
Premises: Every licensed vendor meets the safety standard. Every audited vendor meets the safety standard.
Conclusions: I. Every licensed vendor is audited. II. Every audited vendor is licensed.
A Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
B Only Conclusion I follows
C Only Conclusion II follows
D Both Conclusions I and II follow
Answer: A. Neither Conclusion I nor II follows. Sharing the safety standard does not establish either group includes the other.
Premises: If a file is encrypted, a recovery key is stored. No recovery key was stored for File R.
Conclusions: I. File R was not encrypted. II. If a recovery key is stored, the file is encrypted.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Only Conclusion I follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: B. Only Conclusion I follows. The missing key rules out encryption under the stated rule; the rule cannot be reversed.
Premises: If the first bus is full, the dispatcher sends another bus. Another bus was sent.
Conclusions: I. The first bus was full. II. If the first bus was not full, no other bus was sent.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Only Conclusion II follows
C Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
D Both Conclusions I and II follow
Answer: C. Neither Conclusion I nor II follows. A second bus could have been sent for another reason, and the rule does not state what happens when the first bus is not full.
Premises: Every analyst who requested a data export received an audit log. Some analysts requested a data export.
Conclusions: I. Some analysts received an audit log. II. Every analyst received an audit log.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
D Only Conclusion I follows
Answer: D. Only Conclusion I follows. The export-requesting analysts received logs; nothing is said about analysts who did not request an export.
Premises: In the review queue, Request A is ahead of Request B. Request B is ahead of Request C.
Conclusions: I. Request A is ahead of Request C. II. Request C is ahead of Request A.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Only Conclusion II follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: A. Only Conclusion I follows. The two stated orderings place A before C.
Premises: No returned item is discarded. Some defective items were returned.
Conclusions: I. Some defective items were not discarded. II. No discarded item was returned.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Only Conclusion II follows
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: B. Both Conclusions I and II follow. The returned defective items are not discarded, and the first premise also excludes any discarded item from being returned.
Premises: A permit is approved only if the inspection is complete. The inspection is complete.
Conclusions: I. The permit must be approved. II. If a permit is approved, the inspection is complete.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Only Conclusion II follows
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: C. Only Conclusion II follows. Completing the inspection is necessary but not sufficient; the second conclusion restates the rule.
Premises: A proposal is funded only if its budget is approved. Its budget is approved only if its plan is reviewed.
Conclusions: I. If the proposal is funded, its plan was reviewed. II. If the plan was reviewed, the proposal is funded.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
D Only Conclusion I follows
Answer: D. Only Conclusion I follows. Funding requires an approved budget and a reviewed plan; review alone does not guarantee funding.
Premises: For the project to proceed, at least one of its internal budget or external grant must be approved. The project is proceeding, and the internal budget is not approved.
Conclusions: I. The external grant is approved. II. The internal budget is not approved.
A Both Conclusions I and II follow
B Only Conclusion I follows
C Only Conclusion II follows
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: A. Both Conclusions I and II follow. Since the project proceeds and the budget is not approved, the grant must be approved; the budget fact is also explicit.
Premises: Some archived photos are tagged. Every tagged photo is searchable. Every searchable photo has a date label.
Conclusions: I. Some archived photos have a date label. II. Every archived photo has a date label.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Only Conclusion I follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: B. Only Conclusion I follows. The tagged archived photos are searchable and date-labeled; the premises do not cover every archived photo.
Premises: Job A is scheduled before Job B. Job B is scheduled before Job C.
Conclusions: I. Job A is scheduled before Job C. II. Job C is scheduled before Job A.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Only Conclusion I follows
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: C. Only Conclusion I follows. The two order relations put A before C.
Premises: Only a manager may sign the final approval form. Lee signed the final approval form.
Conclusions: I. Lee is a manager. II. Every manager signed the final approval form.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
D Only Conclusion I follows
Answer: D. Only Conclusion I follows. Signing is restricted to managers, but not every manager is said to have signed.
Premises: No archived record is temporary. Every temporary record is editable.
Conclusions: I. No temporary record is archived. II. No editable record is archived.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Only Conclusion II follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: A. Only Conclusion I follows. Temporary records are excluded from the archive; editable records need not all be temporary.
Premises: If the backup generator fails, the warning buzzer sounds. The warning buzzer did not sound.
Conclusions: I. The backup generator did not fail. II. The fuel tank is full.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Only Conclusion I follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: B. Only Conclusion I follows. The quiet buzzer rules out the failure described by the rule; fuel level is not given.
Premises: Some applications were approved. Every approved application has a timestamp.
Conclusions: I. Some applications have a timestamp. II. Every application with a timestamp was approved.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Only Conclusion I follows
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: C. Only Conclusion I follows. The approved applications have timestamps; a timestamp alone does not prove approval.
Premises: Every document in Archive Z is digitized. No digitized file is editable in the public viewer.
Conclusions: I. No Archive Z document is editable in the public viewer. II. No file editable in the public viewer is in Archive Z.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Only Conclusion II follows
C Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
D Both Conclusions I and II follow
Answer: D. Both Conclusions I and II follow. Archive Z documents are digitized and therefore not editable; the groups are disjoint in either direction.
Premises: A shipment reaches the warehouse only if its label is valid. Shipment S has an invalid label.
Conclusions: I. Shipment S has not reached the warehouse. II. Shipment S was delayed by bad weather.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Only Conclusion II follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: A. Only Conclusion I follows. Arrival requires a valid label, so an invalid label rules out arrival; weather is not mentioned.
Premises: If the sensor reports a leak, the valve is closed. If the valve is closed, the pump stops. The pump has not stopped.
Conclusions: I. The sensor did not report a leak. II. The valve is not closed.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Only Conclusion II follows
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: B. Both Conclusions I and II follow. A running pump rules out a closed valve, which rules out a leak report under the chain.
Premises: Either the review committee approved the plan or returned it for revision. The plan was not returned.
Conclusions: I. The committee approved the plan. II. The plan was not returned.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Only Conclusion II follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: C. Both Conclusions I and II follow. The stated alternatives and no return require approval; the second fact is also given.