Premises: If a user has approved access, the user’s badge activates. Badge B is active.
Conclusions: I. User B must have approved access. II. If User B’s badge is not active, User B does not have approved access.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Only Conclusion II follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: B. Only Conclusion II follows. The first conclusion affirms the consequent and is invalid; the second is the valid contrapositive of the rule.
Premises: If a report is archived, it receives a reference ID. Report R has no reference ID.
Conclusions: I. Report R was not archived. II. Report R was deleted.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Only Conclusion I follows
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: C. Only Conclusion I follows. An archived report must have an ID, so the missing ID rules out archiving; deletion is not established.
Premises: A permit is issued only after its fee is paid. Permit P was issued.
Conclusions: I. The fee for Permit P was paid. II. Paying the fee always guarantees that a permit is issued.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
D Only Conclusion I follows
Answer: D. Only Conclusion I follows. Issuance requires payment, but payment alone may not satisfy other requirements.
Premises: Every evening class has a room code. Some language classes are evening classes.
Conclusions: I. Some language classes have a room code. II. Every language class is an evening class.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Only Conclusion II follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: A. Only Conclusion I follows. The language classes that are evening classes have room codes; the premise does not cover every language class.
Premises: All approved suppliers pass a quality review. Supplier K passed a quality review.
Conclusions: I. Supplier K is approved. II. Every supplier that passes review is approved.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
C Only Conclusion II follows
D Both Conclusions I and II follow
Answer: B. Neither Conclusion I nor II follows. Passing review is necessary for approval, but the reverse implication is not given.
Premises: Only certified technicians may inspect this machine. Dara inspected the machine.
Conclusions: I. Dara is a certified technician. II. Every certified technician inspected this machine.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Only Conclusion I follows
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: C. Only Conclusion I follows. Inspection is restricted to certified technicians; that does not mean all certified technicians inspected it.
Premises: No archived record is altered. Every legal record in the registry is archived.
Conclusions: I. No legal record in the registry is altered. II. No altered record in the registry is a legal record.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Only Conclusion II follows
C Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
D Both Conclusions I and II follow
Answer: D. Both Conclusions I and II follow. Legal records in the registry are archived, and archived records are unaltered; therefore neither form of the overlap is possible.
Premises: Some users enable two-factor sign-in. Every user with two-factor sign-in can reset a forgotten password online.
Conclusions: I. Some users can reset a forgotten password online. II. Every user can reset a forgotten password online.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Only Conclusion II follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: A. Only Conclusion I follows. Users who enabled two-factor sign-in can reset online, but the premises do not cover everyone.
Premises: If a machine overheats, its red indicator turns on. The red indicator is off.
Conclusions: I. The machine did not overheat. II. The machine is fully operational.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Only Conclusion I follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: B. Only Conclusion I follows. The rule and an off indicator rule out overheating, but say nothing about other faults.
Premises: If a parcel is fragile, staff attach a fragile label. Parcel Q has no fragile label.
Conclusions: I. Parcel Q is not classified as fragile. II. Parcel Q was damaged in transit.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Only Conclusion I follows
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: C. Only Conclusion I follows. A fragile parcel would be labeled, so the absence of that label rules out the classification under the rule; damage is unknown.
Premises: A request is logged only if it has a reference number. A request is logged only if it has a timestamp.
Conclusions: I. If a request is logged, it has both a reference number and a timestamp. II. Any request with a reference number and timestamp is logged.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
D Only Conclusion I follows
Answer: D. Only Conclusion I follows. Both details are necessary for logging, but having both is not said to guarantee logging.
Premises: If a key is in the safe, the safe door is locked. The safe door is locked.
Conclusions: I. The key must be in the safe. II. If the key is not in the safe, the safe door is unlocked.
A Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
B Only Conclusion I follows
C Only Conclusion II follows
D Both Conclusions I and II follow
Answer: A. Neither Conclusion I nor II follows. The locked door could have another cause, and the first rule gives no result when the key is absent.
Premises: Some runners are volunteers. Every volunteer attends the event briefing.
Conclusions: I. Some runners attend the event briefing. II. Every person at the briefing is a runner.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Only Conclusion I follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: B. Only Conclusion I follows. The runner-volunteers attend, but there may be other briefing attendees.
Premises: Every invoice is verified before it is paid. Invoice D has been paid.
Conclusions: I. Invoice D was verified. II. Every verified invoice is paid.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Only Conclusion I follows
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: C. Only Conclusion I follows. Payment requires prior verification; verification alone does not guarantee payment.
Premises: Exactly one of Task A or Task B is assigned. Task A is not assigned.
Conclusions: I. Task B is assigned. II. Task A is not assigned.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Only Conclusion II follows
C Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
D Both Conclusions I and II follow
Answer: D. Both Conclusions I and II follow. With exactly one assigned and A unassigned, B must be assigned; A’s absence is also explicitly given.
Premises: Exactly one of Route X or Route Y is open. Route X is closed.
Conclusions: I. Route Y is open. II. Route X is closed.
A Both Conclusions I and II follow
B Only Conclusion I follows
C Only Conclusion II follows
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: A. Both Conclusions I and II follow. The exclusive choice makes Y open when X is closed, and X’s closure is stated.
Premises: If a sensor loses power, its alarm triggers. The alarm triggered.
Conclusions: I. The sensor lost power. II. If the sensor has power, the alarm cannot trigger.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
C Only Conclusion II follows
D Both Conclusions I and II follow
Answer: B. Neither Conclusion I nor II follows. The alarm may have other triggers; neither conclusion follows from the one-way rule.
Premises: Every record with a valid checksum passes the integrity check. Record M has an invalid checksum.
Conclusions: I. Record M does not have a valid checksum. II. Record M is corrupted.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Only Conclusion I follows
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: C. Only Conclusion I follows. The first conclusion restates the fact; invalid checksum alone does not prove the record’s cause or condition.
Premises: No draft is published without review. Draft A was published.
Conclusions: I. Draft A was reviewed. II. Draft A was published.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Only Conclusion II follows
C Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
D Both Conclusions I and II follow
Answer: D. Both Conclusions I and II follow. Publication requires review, and publication is explicitly stated.
Premises: Every admitted visitor must show identification. Some students showed identification.
Conclusions: I. Some students were admitted. II. Every admitted visitor showed identification.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Only Conclusion I follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: A. Only Conclusion II follows. The second conclusion restates the rule; showing identification alone does not prove admission.
Premises: Some meeting attendees take notes. Some note takers joined remotely.
Conclusions: I. Some meeting attendees joined remotely. II. Some note takers are meeting attendees.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Only Conclusion II follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: B. Only Conclusion II follows. The first premise guarantees that some attendees are note takers; overlap with remote note takers is not established.
Premises: No encrypted message is public. Some emergency alerts are public.
Conclusions: I. Some emergency alerts are not encrypted. II. Every emergency alert is encrypted.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Only Conclusion I follows
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: C. Only Conclusion I follows. The public alerts cannot be encrypted under the first premise; the premise does not classify every alert.
Premises: If all project tasks are complete, the project closes. The project has not closed.
Conclusions: I. Not all project tasks are complete. II. The project has failed permanently.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Both Conclusions I and II follow
C Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
D Only Conclusion I follows
Answer: D. Only Conclusion I follows. The contrapositive rules out all tasks being complete; permanent failure is not stated.
Premises: A project can launch only if its budget is approved. The budget is not approved.
Conclusions: I. The project cannot launch. II. The project has been canceled.
A Only Conclusion I follows
B Only Conclusion II follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: A. Only Conclusion I follows. Budget approval is required for launch, but lack of approval does not prove cancellation.
Premises: If the store opens on Sunday, the staff schedule is changed. The staff schedule was not changed.
Conclusions: I. The store will not open on Sunday. II. The store has closed permanently.
A Only Conclusion II follows
B Only Conclusion I follows
C Both Conclusions I and II follow
D Neither Conclusion I nor II follows
Answer: B. Only Conclusion I follows. The unchanged schedule rules out a Sunday opening under the rule; permanent closure is not implied.