Statements: All roses are flowers. All flowers are plants. Conclusions: I. All roses are plants. II. All plants are roses.
A Conclusion I only
B Conclusion II only
C Both conclusions I and II
D Neither conclusion I nor II
Answer: A. Conclusion I only. Roses are inside flowers, and flowers inside plants; all roses are plants, but the reverse is not implied.
Statements: All novels are books. Some books are illustrated. Conclusions: I. Some novels are illustrated. II. All books are novels.
A Conclusion I only
B Neither conclusion I nor II
C Conclusion II only
D Both conclusions I and II
Answer: B. Neither conclusion I nor II. The illustrated books need not be novels, and books need not all be novels.
Statements: Some nurses are musicians. All musicians are artists. Conclusions: I. Some nurses are artists. II. Some artists are nurses.
A Conclusion I only
B Conclusion II only
C Both conclusions I and II
D Neither conclusion I nor II
Answer: C. Both conclusions I and II. Those nurses who are musicians are artists; the same group establishes both conclusions.
Statements: No metal objects are wooden. Some toys are wooden. Conclusions: I. Some toys are not metal objects. II. Some toys are metal objects.
A Conclusion II only
B Both conclusions I and II
C Neither conclusion I nor II
D Conclusion I only
Answer: D. Conclusion I only. The wooden toys cannot be metal objects, so some toys are non-metal; no evidence says any are metal.
Statements: All buses are vehicles. No vehicle is a flower. Conclusions: I. No bus is a flower. II. No flower is a bus.
A Both conclusions I and II
B Conclusion I only
C Conclusion II only
D Neither conclusion I nor II
Answer: A. Both conclusions I and II. Buses are vehicles and vehicles are disjoint from flowers; the disjoint relation works both ways.
Statements: Some poets are teachers. Some teachers are runners. Conclusions: I. Some poets are runners. II. Some runners are teachers.
A Conclusion I only
B Conclusion II only
C Both conclusions I and II
D Neither conclusion I nor II
Answer: B. Conclusion II only. Some teachers are runners converts to some runners being teachers; the two 'some' groups may differ.
Statements: All squares are rectangles. Some rectangles are blue. Conclusions: I. Some squares are blue. II. Some blue objects are rectangles.
A Conclusion I only
B Both conclusions I and II
C Conclusion II only
D Neither conclusion I nor II
Answer: C. Conclusion II only. The premise guarantees some blue rectangles, but they need not be squares.
Statements: No fish are birds. Some pets are fish. Conclusions: I. Some pets are not birds. II. No pet is a bird.
A Conclusion II only
B Both conclusions I and II
C Neither conclusion I nor II
D Conclusion I only
Answer: D. Conclusion I only. The pet-fish are not birds; other pets could be birds, so only I follows.
Statements: All laptops are devices. All devices use power. Conclusions: I. All laptops use power. II. All things that use power are laptops.
A Conclusion I only
B Conclusion II only
C Both conclusions I and II
D Neither conclusion I nor II
Answer: A. Conclusion I only. The chain gives laptopβdeviceβuses power; it does not reverse the chain.
Statements: Some apples are green. All green apples are ripe. Conclusions: I. Some apples are ripe. II. All apples are ripe.
A Conclusion II only
B Conclusion I only
C Both conclusions I and II
D Neither conclusion I nor II
Answer: B. Conclusion I only. The green apples are ripe, so some apples are ripe; the premise does not cover every apple.
Statements: No glass objects are flexible. Some bottles are glass objects. Conclusions: I. Some bottles are not flexible. II. No bottle is flexible.
A Conclusion II only
B Both conclusions I and II
C Conclusion I only
D Neither conclusion I nor II
Answer: C. Conclusion I only. The glass bottles are not flexible; other bottles may be flexible.
Statements: All doctors are graduates. Some graduates are researchers. Conclusions: I. Some doctors are researchers. II. Some researchers are graduates.
A Conclusion I only
B Both conclusions I and II
C Neither conclusion I nor II
D Conclusion II only
Answer: D. Conclusion II only. Some graduates are researchers converts to some researchers being graduates; they need not be doctors.
Statements: All cats are mammals. No mammal is a reptile. Conclusions: I. No cat is a reptile. II. No reptile is a cat.
A Both conclusions I and II
B Conclusion I only
C Conclusion II only
D Neither conclusion I nor II
Answer: A. Both conclusions I and II. Cats are mammals, and mammals are disjoint from reptiles; the disjoint relation is mutual.
Statements: Some books are novels. All novels are fiction. Conclusions: I. Some books are fiction. II. All books are fiction.
A Conclusion II only
B Conclusion I only
C Both conclusions I and II
D Neither conclusion I nor II
Answer: B. Conclusion I only. The books that are novels are fiction; other books may not be.
Statements: Some cars are electric. All electric cars are silent. Conclusions: I. Some cars are silent. II. Some silent cars are electric.
A Conclusion I only
B Conclusion II only
C Both conclusions I and II
D Neither conclusion I nor II
Answer: C. Both conclusions I and II. The electric cars in the some-group are silent, establishing both statements.
Statements: All mugs are cups. No cup is a plate. Conclusions: I. No mug is a plate. II. No plate is a mug.
A Conclusion I only
B Conclusion II only
C Neither conclusion I nor II
D Both conclusions I and II
Answer: D. Both conclusions I and II. Mugs are cups, and cups are disjoint from plates; the disjoint relation is mutual.
Statements: All letters are symbols. Some symbols are numbers. Conclusions: I. Some letters are numbers. II. Some numbers are symbols.
A Conclusion II only
B Conclusion I only
C Both conclusions I and II
D Neither conclusion I nor II
Answer: A. Conclusion II only. Some symbols are numbers converts to some numbers being symbols; they need not be letters.
Statements: Some athletes are students. All students are readers. Conclusions: I. Some athletes are readers. II. All athletes are readers.
A Conclusion II only
B Conclusion I only
C Both conclusions I and II
D Neither conclusion I nor II
Answer: B. Conclusion I only. Some athlete-students are readers; the premise does not include all athletes.
Statements: No winter days are hot. Some days are winter days. Conclusions: I. Some days are not hot. II. No day is hot.
A Conclusion II only
B Both conclusions I and II
C Conclusion I only
D Neither conclusion I nor II
Answer: C. Conclusion I only. The winter days in the some-group are not hot; other days may be hot.
Statements: All A are B. Some B are C. Conclusions: I. Some A are C. II. Some C are B.
A Conclusion I only
B Both conclusions I and II
C Neither conclusion I nor II
D Conclusion II only
Answer: D. Conclusion II only. Some B are C converts to some C are B; the some B group need not be A.
Statements: All pencils are writing tools. No writing tool is edible. Conclusions: I. No pencil is edible. II. No edible thing is a pencil.
A Both conclusions I and II
B Conclusion I only
C Conclusion II only
D Neither conclusion I nor II
Answer: A. Both conclusions I and II. Pencils are writing tools, all disjoint from edible things; the disjoint relation works both ways.
Statements: Some workers are artists. All artists are creative. Conclusions: I. Some workers are creative. II. Some creative people are artists.
A Conclusion I only
B Both conclusions I and II
C Conclusion II only
D Neither conclusion I nor II
Answer: B. Both conclusions I and II. The worker-artists are creative, and those same people are creative artists.
Statements: Some birds are pets. No pet is wild. Conclusions: I. Some birds are not wild. II. No bird is wild.
A Conclusion II only
B Both conclusions I and II
C Conclusion I only
D Neither conclusion I nor II
Answer: C. Conclusion I only. The bird-pets are not wild, but other birds may be wild.
Statements: All triangles are polygons. Some polygons are regular. Conclusions: I. Some triangles are regular. II. Some regular polygons are polygons.
A Conclusion I only
B Both conclusions I and II
C Neither conclusion I nor II
D Conclusion II only
Answer: D. Conclusion II only. The regular polygons need not be triangles; the some regular polygons are still polygons.
Statements: Some students are not athletes. All students are young. Conclusions: I. Some young people are not athletes. II. Some students are young.
A Both conclusions I and II
B Conclusion I only
C Conclusion II only
D Neither conclusion I nor II
Answer: A. Both conclusions I and II. The stated students are young and not athletes, so both conclusions follow.